The Captive/La Captive

Starring:Stanislas Merhar, Sylvie Testud, Olivia Bonamy, Liliane RovÃ¨re, FranÃ§oise Bertin, Aurore ClÃ©ment, Vanessa LarrÃ©, Samuel Tasinaje, Jean Borodine, Anna Mouglalis, BÃ©rÃ©nice Bejo, Adeline Chaudron, Sophie Assante, Christopher Gendreau, SÃ©bastien Haddouk, Xavier Morange, Stanislas Januskiewicz, Laurence Guillet, Pascal Erizabal, Claude Hermann
Director: Chantal Akerman
Studio: Image Entertainment
Product Type: DVD

Amazon.com

Along with his status as an important postwar writer of the New Novel school, Alain Robbe-Grillet's place in film history is secure thanks to his debut screenwriting effort, Last Year at Marienbad, the all-time puzzle picture. His own directing efforts have been less accessible outside France, but the 1983 La Belle Captive represents the Robbe-Grillet idea. R-G based the movie on his own novel, which was itself inspired by the paintings of Magritte. The set-up is one of those nightmare-chasing-its-own-tail scenarios: a man (Daniel Mesguich) becomes entranced by a young woman (Gabrielle Lazure) dancing in a nightclub, but later that night he finds her crumpled body on the road. The woman becomes his obsession; meanwhile, his boss (who happens to be a hot babe on a motorcycle) gives him a mysterious assignment. Any initial intrigue on either the erotic or whodunit front quickly dissipates in a maddening series of teases, and even if you like reality/fantasy/dream interplay, your patience may grow thin after a while. The movie's cheapjack '80s look doesn't help, but more than anything La Belle Captive reminds us of the difference between a writer, however talented, and a real director, like Alain Resnais. Resnais' direction of Last Year at Marienbad is an elegant glide into ever-deepening mysteries of place, personality, and memory, but Robbe-Grillet's direction of La Belle Captive never finds wings for its ideas. --Robert Horton

Description

Alain Robbe-Grillet's erotically-charged film portrays a married man's obsession with a mysterious woman who steps out of his fantasies. Walter (Daniel Mesguich) becomes fascinated with Marie-Ange (Gabrielle Lazure) after seeing her in a nightclub. One evening he finds her bound in the middle of the road. After a surreal night of passion, he awakens the next morning wondering if it all was just a dream.

A sensuous, surreal drama in the manner of EYES WIDE SHUT and MULHOLLAND DRIVE

Customer Reviews:

mildly amused.......2007-04-02

cinematography of poetic images is fairly good. The plot, however, is based on unreality and confusion about realtiy and may not interest the more concretely based. Definitly not a thriller, but nice to watch.

If Lynch and Eisenstein teamed up to do 'Chinatown' as a vampire story.......2007-03-28

You'd get something like `La Belle Captive'. Because this movie, written and directed by Alain Robbe-Grillet, is wildly at odds with what most people expect in a film, I am breaking my review into three parts. First, I'll take a stab at listing some films or genres which bear some affinities (however distant) to the sort of animal we're considering here, which hopefully might indicate that a purchaser will enjoy the flick. Then I'll discuss the movie itself with perhaps a bit of technical appreciation, and then finally take a look at the director's theory of storytelling.

If you've seen the famous Resnais/Robbe-Grillet collaboration Last Year at Marienbad, this is more and better (I enjoyed the cinematography more in "La Belle Captive" and found the world, the characters and their story potentials much richer). Now the promised list: noir is a good place to start, films like "Chinatown" or "Somewhere in the Night" with their evolving polymorphic characters, stylized scenes and constantly thwarted plot expectations have a lot in common with "La Belle Captive". Also, the nonlinear fragmented collage of `La Belle Captive' may be attractive to fans of `Eraserhead' or `Memento' or `Dark City' or `Pulp Fiction' or `Satyricon'. Speaking of the editing, Robbe-Grillet plays games with time and space similar to what Maya Deren does in `Meshes of the Afternoon'.

We first meet the protagonist Walter in a nightclub, where he confesses that he doesn't really know or remember what he's doing there, watching stroboscopically lit couples dancing robotically. With moves that would do Lulu proud, a slinky blonde flirts with him. Though he poses at the bar like Bond or Mike Hammer, and Walter and the girl bump and grind on the dance-floor, he can't get the girls name, phone number or address, though she promises that she'll find him, if she needs to. In the voiceover we learn he's a secret agent. His boss/handler calls for Walter at the bar to arrange for a rendezvous that night, and after the call, the girl has disappeared. The meeting is in a backlit, foggy graveyard. The boss, Sara Zeitgeist is a sultry Emma Peale type (her leather bodysuit is open to reveal a fluffly and frilly blouse front) and she is revealed to be the woman driving the black motorcycle who's mysteriously been popping up between scenes throughout the credits and beginning of the movie. Curiously, the normal filmic interpretation suggests that she was on her black and chrome bike when she made the call, since we see her hurling down the road before and after the call. Sara gives her subordinate a letter that must be delivered to Count Henri de Corinthe, preferably that night. When he heads off on his mission, Walter sees the mystery girl lying injured in the road, with her hands cuffed behind her back. Mission forgotten, he takes the girl to a nearby mansion where they interrupt a formal party of strange and ominous men, but finally manages to get a doctor to escort them to a bedroom. The doctor locks them in the room and leaves them there. After a night of vampiric bloodthirsty passion (Walter seems to be sick or only semiconscious) he awakens alone in a ruined mansion. Then the movie starts to get really weird, he drives around and doesn't recognize the streets or buildings, ends up investigating the disappearance (and possible death perhaps the night before, perhaps 7 years before) of his lover, the bite wound on his neck comes and goes, he starts meeting the same actors playing different roles seemingly without recognizing them, manages to become the prime suspect in the kidnapping of the fiancee of the man he was supposed to meet, encounters a mad scientist, and beomes increasingly involved in visions or dreams of his lover on a beach in Uruguay. Walter is buffeted through all these scenarios by necessities he hardly questions and is driven by his passion for his lover and the orders of his boss. I said that I'd mention a couple technical points--this movie is constructed like some of the old silent films, which in a lot ways echo the current theory and practice of comic books, in which the images are central and the dialogue subordinate (though very important for moving the story along). The camera work is very static, and unlike some cinematographers who use fixed framing for a feeling of candidness, Robbe-Grillet makes us conscious that the image is imposed on us and artificial. The sets and scenes and costuming are all very stylized, almost fetishistic (Walter is a detective when he's in his trenchcoat).

If you've never seen any of Robbe-Grillet's work before, you'll be hard pressed to figure out what's going on. On the other hand, if you've gone beyond a casual acquaintance with Robbe-Grillet, then you've likely developed a masochistic craving for the stylish presentation of insoluble puzzles. Robbe-Grillet builds his plots around the natural human tendency to fit pieces together into familiar patterns, he's playing with his audience's expectations. As with the standard and very formulaic cinematic fare, the viewer strives to forge links that will tie all the elements into tidy coherent whole, one which will resolve all the apparent anomalies. It's odd, in the real world we don't have any certainty that we can construct such a narratve, but we are confident we can do so in art. However, rather than a complete story emerging from the mass of disparities, multiple counterfeit stories are struck simultaneously and are both affirmed and invalidated at every turn. Accepting a particular narrative involves surpressing the alternatives, like those pictures which either look like a vase or two faces and as new scenes unfold, one view may be favored or a new one start to coalesce. The whole approach is very much like the old noir movies, except no final revelation ties everything together (though in a few of the old classics, such as Suspicion or Rebecca, the audience may find themselves dissatisfied with an `explanation' that the characters in the movie accept).

Average customer rating:

Kimstim Collection: La Captive
Starring: Françoise Bertin , Aurore Clément , Liliane Rovere , Sylvie Testud , and Olivia Bonamy
Director: Chantal Akerman
Manufacturer: Kino Video
ProductGroup: DVD
Binding: DVD

General | Art House & International | Genres | DVD | Video

General | Drama | Genres | DVD | Video

General | Foreign & International | Stores | DVD | Video

( K ) | Titles | Features | DVD | Video
Similar Items:

Flower and Snake II
The Conformist (Extended Edition)
Flower & Snake
1900 (Special Collector's Edition)
Hail Mary

ASIN: B00092ZMFM
Release Date: 2005-05-10

Average customer rating:

"I hide nothing--nothing that concerns you."
Brutally direct look at obsession.
Better than Ambien

The Captive/La Captive
Starring: Stanislas Merhar , Sylvie Testud , Olivia Bonamy , Liliane Rovère , and Françoise Bertin
Director: Chantal Akerman
Manufacturer: Image Entertainment
ProductGroup: DVD
Binding: DVD

General | Art House & International | Genres | DVD | Video

General | Drama | Genres | DVD | Video

General | Foreign & International | Stores | DVD | Video

( C ) | Titles | Features | DVD | Video
Similar Items:

The Conformist (Extended Edition)
Tomorrow We Move
The Story of Marie and Julien
The War Game/Culloden
Wild Camp

ASIN: B0000YEDZ4
Release Date: 2004-01-27

Description

Handsome and hopelessly neurotic Simon (Stanislas Merhar) lives in a labyrinthine Parisian apartment with his ailing grandmother (Last Year at Marienbad"s Francoise Bertin) and Ariane (Sylvie Testud), the object of his unquenchable desire. Obsessed, Simon keeps Ariane as his willing captive; she tolerates his endless interrogations and surveillance but is able to maintain her own reserve of privacy and freedom. However, she leads a passionate double life with other women that magnifies Simon"s pain and culminates in a devastating finale. Directed by international film sensation Chantal Akerman (A Couch in New York, Night and Day), inspired by Marcel Proust"s La Prisonniere.

Customer Reviews:

"I hide nothing--nothing that concerns you.".......2007-01-17

Chantal Ackerman's film "La Captive" is a story of passion and obsession. Simon (Stanislas Merhar) is a wealthy, reclusive young Parisian who lives with his grandmother and a young woman called Ariane (Sylvie Testud). Ariane, the captive of the title, leads a bizarre life with Simon. She's certainly not his equal, and she spends her days attending singing and trapeze lessons, and wandering around museums. At night, Simon summons and dismisses her from his bedchamber. While their relationship would almost seem to mirror that of a master and a concubine, on another level, Simon is also obsessively controlling and wildly jealous. When Ariane showers, he watches, and suspecting that she has a secret life apart from him, he constantly questions her--and even sends her friend Andree (Olivia Bonamy) to accompany Ariane on outings. The idea is that Andree will escort Ariane and then report back, but even this doesn't satisfy Simon's suspicions. As a result, he begins following both women when they go on excursions together.

Ariane is an amazingly passive character. When Simon's questions and mental probing become too much, she feigns sleep, but even then Simon still hounds her. She never appears ruffled or impatient with Simon's constant interrogation. But no matter what she tells him or what she reveals, it's never enough for Simon. He's insatiably possessive and he's quite aware that Ariane is holding back, and this just frustrates him more than ever.

As a study in obsessive jealousy and the need to possess a lover both mentally and physically, "La Captive" captures the pathology of Simon's relationship with Ariane. She maintains a citadel of the mind that is impenetrable--even though under constant assault. This dark tale of passion, however, is strangely dispassionate, so that ultimately the story and its characters are rather cold. Passions boil under the surface, but they're so deep, one wishes for some explosion during the film. There are long, boring sequences of Simon following Ariane by foot and by car, and while the film successfully conveys Ariane's suffocating existence, it's difficult to imagine them continuing in this vein without a quarrel or two--or at least some tension. As it is, "La Captive"--while analyzing the relationship--remains a little too analytical, pretentious and inhuman. "La Captive" is an adaptation of Proust's "La Prisoniere" (from "Remembrance of Things Past"). In French with subtitles--displacedhuman

Brutally direct look at obsession........2006-11-10

Simon is a writer with an endless supply of nice suits and gorgeous furnishings, living in a beautiful apartment with his girlfriend Ariane, and his ailing mother. The Paris apartment is large, lovely, and currently under renovation; as Simon never seems to do any work, one wonders how he can afford such things. Ariane is the soft-spoken embodiment of the caged bird, a lesbian who allows herself to be kept with Simon, enduring his uncomfortable and odd sexual encounters. Simon, fearing Ariane is not fully his, wants desperately to possess Ariane so much so that his days and nights are filled with interrogations, accusations, and spying. Unsatisfied, he delves deeper into his obsession.

The film is a slow-paced, dreamlike adaptation of the Proust novel. It's somewhat simplified and the dialogue doesn't evoke the depth it's obviously intended to at times. What some would call tedious is actually a brutal and direct view of the deliberate pace of Simon's obsession with Ariane.

Better than Ambien.......2004-12-30

This movie is unbelievably soporific. Apart from the Paris scenery - it lacks any merit - I'm sure that the piece from which Proust is touted to have inspired this boring, self indulgent piece of cinema had redeeming context. This has none. What a waste!

Average customer rating:

"I hide nothing--nothing that concerns you."
Brutally direct look at obsession.
Better than Ambien

La Captive [Region 2]
Starring: Stanislas Merhar , Sylvie Testud , Olivia Bonamy , Liliane Rovère , and Françoise Bertin
Director: Chantal Akerman
ProductGroup: DVD
Binding: DVD

General | Drama | Genres | DVD | Video

( L ) | Titles | Features | DVD | Video
Similar Items:

The Conformist (Extended Edition)
Tomorrow We Move
The Story of Marie and Julien
The War Game/Culloden
Wild Camp

ASIN: B00005NZHR

Customer Reviews:

"I hide nothing--nothing that concerns you.".......2007-01-17

Brutally direct look at obsession........2006-11-10

Better than Ambien.......2004-12-30

DVD:

DVD

How the Grinch Stole Christmas!/If I Ran the Zoo (REGION 1)

DVD: Whisper Kill

Ground Zero